The Paulownia SCAM and how to avoid it

by | Feb 23, 2018 | Environment, Trees

“Scam! BS! I’ll never plant these trees!” These were the kinds of comments we got on our Facebook feed when we started to promote our Free Tree program to farmers in the Southern USA. What was this Paulownia scam thing all about?

The upset revolved around two primary sore points: Firstly the belief that the trees are invasive and might damage the local environment; and second concern that the farmers would be left with acres of worthless timber. Both are very valid concerns.

About 10-15 years ago a group of people, who will remain un-named, started promoting Paulownia to farmers in the Southern States as a ‘get rich scheme’ – the so-called Paulownia Scam.

This group made some horrible mistakes. They sold an invasive variety of the tree (the Paulownia tomentosa) that farmers were told to grow on a 12x12 grid system. The trees were way too close together and grew into skinny beanpole trees, useless for timber.

The farmers, who had paid good money for the trees, were understandably upset and were left with acres of trees for which they had no buyer – this was the Paulownia scam. 

It is heart breaking to hear these stories and it is important to learn from them.  

Don’t plant the tomentosa

Out of the 23 species of Paulownia, there is only one that is invasive – the tomentosa. At World Tree we don’t plant this variety. We have our own premium timber varieties that we grow from tissue culture. Our primary gene stock is from the fortuneii. The seeds are sterile, but even if they weren’t they don’t propagate easily because of the shape of the flute of the flower.

Grow for premium timber

Our foresters have over 30 years experience growing trees for timber. We know how to produce good broad trunks, with minimal knots. Our team visits our farmers at planting time to train them how to prepare the land and plant for the best results. We also provide feedback and advice throughout the years to keep everything on track.

A buyer for the lumber

World Tree is bringing together the buyers for Paulownia lumber. In fact, we already have a waiting list. If you are a farmer that already has Paulownia growing on your land and are interesting in selling it to us, please get in touch.

Free trees? Really – this sounds too good to true.

So perhaps you are still thinking to yourself – well, what’s the catch? How come you are providing the trees for free?

World Tree has been working with farmers for 16 years. We hear your stories and we know that many farmers are suffering. So, we wanted to find a way to work together that was a win-win. We provide the trees, the expertise and the market for the lumber. The farmers provide the land, labor and the TLC to bring the trees to maturity. Together we share in the profits.

World Tree doesn’t make any profit until the trees reach hardwood maturity in 10 years. In other words, we have a lot of skin in the game and a vested interested in making sure our farmers are successful.  

Conclusion: So is this a Paulownia scam? 

No, this is not a Paulownia scam. World Tree is in this for the long haul. We have the trees, growing methods and the expertise to help farmers flourish. We are looking for good farmers with at least 20 acres who are willing to work with us for the benefit of everyone.

 

 

Learn more about our trees and farmers

A Family Affair

A farmer shares his experience of working with World Tree When we first met Will Johnson, he greeted us at his farm in Florida surrounded by his family. We were thrilled when he chose to be come a World Tree farmer and a few months later we interviewed him to find out...

Nature and nurture: Our 2018 trees

Each year we take in a new round of investment and plant a new vintage of trees with our farmers. This spring and summer we have been working with our farmers to plant the trees on behalf of our 2017 investors. Nature and nurture are equally important in developing...

Farmer Progress – 2017 planting

249 acres of trees have been planted on behalf of our 2016 shareholders in Canada, USA and Costa Rica. We have visited about a third of the farmers so far this summer to see how they are doing - and the team will be visiting the remaining farmers over the course of...

Farmer Progress – 2016 planting

Every year World Tree plants a new vintage of trees with our farmers on behalf of our investors. The trees for our 2015 investors were planted with farmers in the Spring and Summer of 2016. These trees all started out as small 'bare roots', that look like a piece of...

0 Comments